MUBAHISA: Surrogate Mother;What is your view

[tauruskhan]

Re: Surrogate Mother : What is your view

yes....ik or ghalat/un-lawful/western cheez part of our society ho jae gi
we must controll it rite now n must not encourage it.....

i think its different from test tube baby concept?

this is the same thing with a new name
check it out both on internet

[tauruskhan]

Re: MUBAHISA: Surrogate Mother;What is your view

Aap ki baat ko ghalat hum kahan keh rahay hein filba bhaiya :) jo mein ne Mehere ko reply kia he us per aap bhi sooch ke apni raaye se nawaziye. aur haan whatever you conclude from my reply should be logical

let me think and check different fatwas

[tauruskhan]

Re: MUBAHISA: Surrogate Mother;What is your view

ISLAMIC VERDICT:

Scholars of Islam have pronounced the following fatwa (Islamic verdict) regarding surrogacy:

It is illegal and immoral to introduce into a woman the sperm of any man other than her husband. The formation of the embryo outside the human body will only be permissible subject to certain strict conditions. It will be Haram (forbidden) to form the embryo by the fusion of a woman's ovum with the sperm of a man other than her husband. It is also not lawful to implant into a woman an embryo developed in a haram way.

Consequently, it will be quite obvious that it is Haram to introduce sperm or embryo into an unmarried woman.

If, in violation of Allah's Law, either the sperm of a man other than the husband's has been introduced into an unmarried woman or a Haram formed embryo has been introduced into a woman, the rulings will be as follows:

1. If the woman is married, the resultant child will legally be that of her husband even if it is confirmed that the sperm used was not that of her husband. 2. The same ruling will apply if the child results from a haram embryo. Even if the embryo was formed by the fusion of the woman's ovum with the sperm of another man, the child will legally be that of her husband. 3. The 'donor' of the sperm has no right whatsoever over the child even if prior agreement or contract was entered into to give him the right over the child. 4. If the woman is unmarried, the resultant child will be illegitimate and would be regarded to be that of the surrogate mother.

Surrogate motherhood is definitely not allowed in Islam due to the fact that many evils may arise from this procedure, which can be listed as follows:

1. Unmarried women could be tempted into 'leasing' their wombs for monetary benefits, which would, in turn, undermine the very institution of marriage and family life. 2. In order to relieve themselves of the agony of childbirth, married women could be tempted to resort to this technique. Islam abhors such action 3. since pregnancy cannot be regarded as a burden, but in fact it is a blessing A woman who passes away whilst in the process of delivering, is given the status of a martyr. 4. A Transvaal (Tzaneen) surrogate grandmother gave birth to her daughter's IVF triplets on October 1987 76 which was a result of the South African Government not clamping down on such practices. Can Pat Anthony's (surrogate mother) action in carrying the children of her biological daughter, Karen, be morally justified? In doing so, she has implanted the sperm of her son-in-law into her womb. Biologically, the surrogate children she gave birth to, would become her daughter, Karen's, brothers and sisters, and at the same time, would be legally regarded as Karen's children. Karen in turn would thus be sharing two types of relationship with the same children. 5. Finally, surrogate motherhood violates the systematic planning of Allah in the normal process of procreation.

ISLAMIC PRINCIPLES ON FAMILY PLANNING, Mufti Allie Haroun Sheik, Qasmi Publication (p. 150 - 153)

[tauruskhan]

[tauruskhan]

Re: MUBAHISA: Surrogate Mother;What is your view

Aap ki baat ko ghalat hum kahan keh rahay hein filba bhaiya :) jo mein ne Mehere ko reply kia he us per aap bhi sooch ke apni raaye se nawaziye. aur haan whatever you conclude from my reply should be logical

app dono fatwas per lain app ko inshallah tasali ho jaeey gi and app key swalat ka answers bi ini main hay

take care

[Mr. Sialkoty]

Re: MUBAHISA: Surrogate Mother;What is your view

Well according to my limited knowledge a woman can't be re-pregnant after already conceiving a pregnency. What happens in two, three or four children, the zygote devides to form multiple zygotes that later on develops into multiple individuals.

After the zygote is placed into the womb it stucks with it and develops link with uteres through its navel card in order to get nutritions for further development. Here occurs a number of hormonal changes in the body of that woman that facilitate the baby to growth and restrict the ovaries to not release the ovum for further furtilization.

If it happens and a diploid furtilization occurs inside the surrogated mother one of donar mother and second of herself, then there is a simple way of identification of which child belongs to which mother through the conduction of DNA (De Oxyribo neuclic acid) test.

What do you say now?

[tauruskhan]

Re: MUBAHISA: Surrogate Mother;What is your view

Well according to my limited knowledge a woman can't be re-pregnant after already conceiving a pregnency. What happens in two, three or four children, the zygote devides to form multiple zygotes that later on develops into multiple individuals.

After the zygote is placed into the womb it stucks with it and develops link with uteres through its navel card in order to get nutritions for further development. Here occurs a number of hormonal changes in the body of that woman that facilitate the baby to growth and restrict the ovaries to not release the ovum for further furtilization.

If it happens and a diploid furtilization occurs inside the surrogated mother one of donar mother and second of herself, then there is a simple way of identification of which child belongs to which mother through the conduction of DNA (De Oxyribo neuclic acid) test.



What do you say now?

i would say that Ummat e Muslima had decided on some thing then i am no one to talk more on this
Ummat e Muslima had decided that it is haram then it is haram

and your supposition are totally supposition

ager youn ho jaey to kia ho ga and woon ho jaey to kia ho ga

Doctors and ulmma is per pehlay hi bohat behsain ker chukain haan and they all have decided that this is haram

[Mr. Sialkoty]

Re: MUBAHISA: Surrogate Mother;What is your view

ok boss

['SamRazi']

Re: MUBAHISA: Surrogate Mother;What is your view

2.) some ladies yeh sochti hain ke maan ban-ne se unki khubsoorti chali jayengi aur profession mein rukawat padegi...(Working women, Actress, Sports woman)

3.) Some ladies ko time pe kahiin attend karna ho, koi task pura karna ho...jaise Tennis player ki khiladi, ya abroad jaaney ka program ho jo life and future ke liye bahut bahut hi zaroori hai, aur pregnancy ke haalat mein travel nahin kar sakti.

sorry SPY mei is topic per behas kerne nahi aayi na kerun gi ......... magar yeh batein parh ker :kr: :kr: :kr: ........... khuda Aurat ko itni aqal aur itni taraqi bhi na dai ke wo apni wajood ka matlab bhi bhool jayeh :tauba

[Mr. Sialkoty]

Re: MUBAHISA: Surrogate Mother;What is your view

dil ko lagti he baat bakri ki

[sanamaftab]

Re: MUBAHISA: Surrogate Mother;What is your view

goog thinking