Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

[Z.]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

but this is also not the solution......
baat karin zaroor karin.......ise ko to debate kehte hain per ik dosre ki zaat per tanqeed mat karin......or aisa 2ono sides se ho raha hai:(

KHUSH RAHYE

[aabi2cool]

Re: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

KHL bhai..........i think ap ziada passionate ho gae.........
dekhin IQBAL hamarey liye qabil-e-izzat shakhsiyat hain,ik acche poet (i do agree unki poetry naseehatoon se bhari hoi hai)
per hum kabhi bhi unki poetry ko QURAN k sath na hi compare ker saktey hain or na us jesa keh sakte hain

QURAAN PAAK ik divine n revealed book hai jis main words as well as meanings sab kuch revealed hai........it means k wo ALLAH TAALA K APNE WORDS hain.......wo ALLAH TAALA ki ik buhaat MUQADDAS KITAAB jo hamarey liye ahkaam or naseehatoon se bhari hoi hai.......
hum NAUZUBILLAH kabhi bhi kise aam insaan ki kitaab ko ALLAH ki KITAAB k saath her giz compare nahi ker sakty.......
is baat ki ijazat to hamaari naqis aqal bhi humin nahi deeti

is baat per sochye samjhye to INSHALLAH apko sab baat khud hi samajh aa jae gi.

AAAP ny bilkul theek kaha hamary khalil bhai khuch ziyada hi jazbati hogay thy aur us ka ye jumla waqe hi qable girfat hy .
meri aaj hi un se is mozo par baat hui hy wo tasleem karty hain laikin un ka matalb wo naheen tha jo k jumly k zahir main hy.balk wo ye kehna chaty thy k iqbal ki aksar shairi quran hi ki tafseer hy .bus zara jazbat main aakar ye keh diya k wo iqbal ki shaire aur quran main koi farq naheen samjhty..
khair ALLAH un ko un ki nadanistgi main is ghalti par moaf farmay kiuonk un ka matlab wo naheen tha jo k jumly k zahir se ayan hy aur wesy bhi ALLAH dilon k hal behtar janta hy...

[Muhammad Khalil]

Re: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

sory ager main koi ghalt baat keh gia.....
ALLAH sab ko moaf kery ameen

[tauruskhan]

Re: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

sory ager main koi ghalt baat keh gia.....
ALLAH sab ko moaf kery ameen

Ameen

[Shaim]

Re: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

AAAP ny bilkul theek kaha hamary khalil bhai khuch ziyada hi jazbati hogay thy aur us ka ye jumla waqe hi qable girfat hy .
meri aaj hi un se is mozo par baat hui hy wo tasleem karty hain laikin un ka matalb wo naheen tha jo k jumly k zahir main hy.balk wo ye kehna chaty thy k iqbal ki aksar shairi quran hi ki tafseer hy .bus zara jazbat main aakar ye keh diya k wo iqbal ki shaire aur quran main koi farq naheen samjhty..
khair ALLAH un ko un ki nadanistgi main is ghalti par moaf farmay kiuonk un ka matlab wo naheen tha jo k jumly k zahir se ayan hy aur wesy bhi ALLAH dilon k hal behtar janta hy...

bilkul sahee:) n now there is no objection
wasy i know unho ne wasa jazbaat mai kaha tha

[Shaim]

Re: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

sory ager main koi ghalt baat keh gia.....
ALLAH sab ko moaf kery ameen

AMEEN!
nahi bhai its ok........
KHUSH RAHYE:)

[*Roomi*]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

:)

[tauruskhan]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

[quote=TheMask;267561]
walikum as salam
main wasey ker chuka hoon mutala
wasey ager arz karoo key main ney perha tha key wo till death tak drinker rahey they
main pehlay arz ker chuka hoon key mujeh wo as a poet bohat acchay lagtey haan sirf
baki her aik ka apna nukta nazar hay
thanx for taking interest and mujeh samjhaney ka thanx

[*Roomi*]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

Usman App nay Kis ka Likha Pera hai ? Jis nay Likha us ki Shaksiyat Aisi hai kay us ki Baat per Yaqeen ker lia jay ??? kia Liknay walay ki Sadaqat ka Yaqeen hai ????

[tauruskhan]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

Usman App nay Kis ka Likha Pera hai ? Jis nay Likha us ki Shaksiyat Aisi hai kay us ki Baat per Yaqeen ker lia jay ??? kia Liknay walay ki Sadaqat ka Yaqeen hai ????

inshallah main app ko check ker kay dobara bataoon ga inshallah

[Shaim]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?


Walikum Assalam!

1stly Welcome @ Behes-o-Mubahisa & Halaat-E-Hazra after a long long time
:):)

& 2ndly Nice Reply!:clap: i think this ll solve the actual problem:)


KHUSH RAHYEE!

[*Roomi*]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

Iqbal wasn't Drinker if any one have Proofs then Display Quickly :)

[Masood]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

01

[Masood]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

02

[Muhammad Khalil]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

02

mashaALLAH bhai aap ny to dood ka dood aur paani ka paani ker dia hay
aap kee tehreer sy mujy buhat kuch pata chala hay Murshad Iqbal k bary main...jo key pehly pata nahi tha....
wakee unoon ny jo kaam ker dikhaya hy shaid kee koi aur kerta....on ka aik share atach ker rha huN