Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

[Shaim]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

nops i don't think so
ager wo na hotey to koi aur hota

:cc: :cc: :D :D Ok
ager Iqbal nahi hoty to filba bhai hoty?rite?:D

[Z.]

Re: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

Iqbal ka name lanay walay uska dia howa ders bhool jaatay hain.bulkay ignore kertay hain. Aik shar hay Iqbal ka,, Aa tujh ko bataon k taqdeerai ummam kia hay,,Shumseer wo sana awal ,tawous rubab aakhir
is share ka saf matlab hayk ..Allah say tauluq or Jihad orooj hay or music etc zawal hay ..khud daikh lu or kisi say pooch bhi lu.

exactly
hum kafi kuch bhool jaatey hein...

aap batana chahein gey key agar Iqbal na hotey to kya kuch missing hota ?

[Z.]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

Assalam-o-Alikum barg sis!:)



u've come with an intresting topic!:clap:
ager Iqbal na hooty to Pakistan ko separate country bananaey ka decision shaid liya hi na jata or ager liya jata to shaiod is main delay ho jata
wo ik buhat acchey SHAAIR they jinhe log aj bhi shoq se perhte hain ik aise shair jinho ne ishq/mohabbat se hatt ker sabaq amooz shaariri bhi ki:)

KHUSH RAHIYE:)

[Z.]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

agar iqbal na hoty to urdu adab main to shayed koi kami na hoti han magar itna zaroor hy k ummate muslima aik bohat bary mufakar aur ummat main aik nai rooh pohnkny wali shaksiyat se mehroom reh jati. han albata 2 qoomi nazariye wali baat ka nata serf hazraty iqbal hi k sath jorna tareeki aytbaar se ghalat hy..iqbal se pehly bhi muslmano main ye nazariya mojood tha haal albata is ko shohrat iqbal hi k fikri pegham se mili.......

Urdu adab mey koi kami na hoti`??

[Z.]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

nops i don't think so
ager wo na hotey to koi aur hota

aap ko maloom hai key iqbal ko is dunya sey gaye huye kitney saal ho gaye hein??

kya hamaray paas aaj un key jaisa sha'ir hai.....?

plus this is not our debate

my q was

Agar Iqbal ka kaam aaj aap urdu adab sey nikal dien to us mey kya kami ho gi?

[tauruskhan]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

aap ko maloom hai key iqbal ko is dunya sey gaye huye kitney saal ho gaye hein??

kya hamaray paas aaj un key jaisa sha'ir hai.....?

plus this is not our debate

my q was

Agar Iqbal ka kaam aaj aap urdu adab sey nikal dien to us mey kya kami ho gi?

do you know Allama Iqbal
no dought he was a great poet
but do you know he was a drinker as well
aik nakam wakeel etc etc

malka bartania key marnay per kia kaha tha
"
utta garb sey aj saya khuda
"
means key malka bartania khuda ka saya thee
astagfiruallah

critics to yeh bi kehtay haan key Iqbal ney us wakat key ik mashoor shair name is wakat meray zehan main naeen hay ki shairi ko copy kia kerta tha

but from my point of view he was a great poet and nothing else
he was not a good leader , not a good lawyer

actually jab hmm kisi ki tareef kerna shorow kertay haan to us key kharab pehloo khatam ker detay haan
thats wrong


but in poetry i admire him , but i don't think key ager wo na hota to urdu adab per zeada farak perta
urdu adab per ager farak per sakta tha to wo ghalib ki shari na honey sey per sakta tha

wasey mujeh yeh samj naeen ati , saray sharabi itni acchi shari kesay ker letay haan
kia acchi poetry baghair sharab peay naeen ho sakti kia

[tauruskhan]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

aap ko maloom hai key iqbal ko is dunya sey gaye huye kitney saal ho gaye hein??

kya hamaray paas aaj un key jaisa sha'ir hai.....?

plus this is not our debate

my q was

Agar Iqbal ka kaam aaj aap urdu adab sey nikal dien to us mey kya kami ho gi?

kia hamain shairoon ki zarorat hay
shair log to wasey bi is dunia per bhoj hotey haan

hmm ko scientist, engineers , workers and doctors ki zarorat hay
aik nakamey , society sey door , sirf shairi main magan logon ki zaroorat naeen hay

[tauruskhan]

Re: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

topic aap ny ejeeb dia hay..................................

waisy ager Iqbal na huty to shaid main yehan na huta,,,,,

kindlay apney signature sey yeh tarakoons ( trucks ) wala sheer to delete kareen

[Shaim]

Re: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

kindlay apney signature sey yeh tarakoons ( trucks ) wala sheer to delete kareen

:na: :na: :shh: :blush:

[Shaim]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

kia hamain shairoon ki zarorat hay
shair log to wasey bi is dunia per bhoj hotey haan

hmm ko scientist, engineers , workers and doctors ki zarorat hay
aik nakamey , society sey door , sirf shairi main magan logon ki zaroorat naeen hay

:budhu: :budhu: :cc: :cc:

[Shaim]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

do you know Allama Iqbal
no dought he was a great poet
but do you know he was a drinker as well
aik nakam wakeel etc etc

malka bartania key marnay per kia kaha tha
"
utta garb sey aj saya khuda
"
means key malka bartania khuda ka saya thee
astagfiruallah

critics to yeh bi kehtay haan key Iqbal ney us wakat key ik mashoor shair name is wakat meray zehan main naeen hay ki shairi ko copy kia kerta tha

but from my point of view he was a great poet and nothing else
he was not a good leader , not a good lawyer

actually jab hmm kisi ki tareef kerna shorow kertay haan to us key kharab pehloo khatam ker detay haan
thats wrong


but in poetry i admire him , but i don't think key ager wo na hota to urdu adab per zeada farak perta
urdu adab per ager farak per sakta tha to wo ghalib ki shari na honey sey per sakta tha

wasey mujeh yeh samj naeen ati , saray sharabi itni acchi shari kesay ker letay haan
kia acchi poetry baghair sharab peay naeen ho sakti kia

:comfort: :budhu: :tauba :blush:

[Z.]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

@ Moderators

Please close this thread!

[Masood]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

Kya aap ko iska mukhtasir sa jawab chahiye ya tafseeli?

[Masood]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

kia hamain shairoon ki zarorat hay
shair log to wasey bi is dunia per bhoj hotey haan

hmm ko scientist, engineers , workers and doctors ki zarorat hay
aik nakamey , society sey door , sirf shairi main magan logon ki zaroorat naeen hay

filba agar bura na manein to aik talakh baat kahoon? Merey bhai aap kisi achhey sey mahir-e-nafsiyaat sey rabta kijiye....

[Z.]

Re: Mubahisa: Agar Iqbal na hotey...?

Kya aap ko iska mukhtasir sa jawab chahiye ya tafseeli?

ab nahi chahiye bro.
Thanks!