MUBAHISA: Music?

[Mr. Sialkoty]

Re: Music?

janab aap ko yaad ho ga keh aap nay is thred main start main mujh say kaha tha keh ''main ghaamdi kay baray main jald hee likhon ga''
yeh alag baat hai keh ab aap apni jaan churwa rahay hain.

Yaar Abid aa jaye ghar phir us se pooch ke likh le ga :hehe:

[*Roomi*]

Re: Music?

prove with proof........................about ghamdi

Proof Itna He Kafi Hai kay Batain Deen-o-Islam ki Kerta Hai or usay Muhabbadt Nahe Sunat-e-Rasool ( SAW ) say Ager Hoti to Cheray per Sunat-e-Rasool (SAW) Zaroor Hoti es say Bara Saboot kia hoga ?

[abdulwahab]

Re: Music?

Yaar Abid aa jaye ghar phir us se pooch ke likh le ga :hehe:

:khi:
abid bhi ka jawaab bhee lazmi yahi ho ga.ager nahi too woh bhe aa jain.:salam:

[abdulwahab]

Re: Music?

Proof Itna He Kafi Hai kay Batain Deen-o-Islam ki Kerta Hai or usay Muhabbadt Nahe Sunat-e-Rasool ( SAW ) say Ager Hoti to Cheray per Sunat-e-Rasool (SAW) Zaroor Hoti es say Bara Saboot kia hoga ?

yeh bhee keh sactay hain lakin khalil ka jawaab anay doo.

[Shaim]

Re: Music?

yupz waiting KHL bhai:)

[Muhammad Khalil]

Re: Music?

Proof Itna He Kafi Hai kay Batain Deen-o-Islam ki Kerta Hai or usay Muhabbadt Nahe Sunat-e-Rasool ( SAW ) say Ager Hoti to Cheray per Sunat-e-Rasool (SAW) Zaroor Hoti es say Bara Saboot kia hoga ?

hahhha kia baat ker di hay aap ny bhai......................


Ghamdi sahib k sary Elam per aap ny apni choti sy baat per paani phairni kee nakam koshash ker hee dali

[Muhammad Khalil]

Re: Music?

yeh bhee keh sactay hain lakin khalil ka jawaab anay doo.

mera jawab koi nahi bus main aap sy proof chahta tha jo aap nahi dy sakty...

[*Roomi*]

Re: Music?

hahhha kia baat ker di hay aap ny bhai......................


Ghamdi sahib k sary Elam per aap ny apni choti sy baat per paani phairni kee nakam koshash ker hee dali

:hathora

[abdulwahab]

Re: Music?

mera jawab koi nahi bus main aap sy proof chahta tha jo aap nahi dy sakty...

khalil sahib aap bachon wali batain too na karain na ab.aap pehlay hee bata daitay keh aap ko kuch nahi pata ghaamdi kay baray main hum nay konsa aap ko kuch keh daina tha chalain koi baat nahi ab bata daitay hain.
''ghaamdi ka pura nam hai javaid ahmed ghamdi aur yeh fitna ''idarah_almoorad'' ka serbarah hai.woh sahib itnay akalmand hain keh unhoon nay puray islam ki aaj tak jitni bhee tashreeh ki gai thi ko reject ker diya hai.ghaamdi ka kehna hai keh main apnay demagh say quraan aur hadees ki tashreh keroon ga.aur sab say bari baat yeh keh us nay hamary''iema_arbah'' ki tashreh ka inkaar ker diya hai.us ki akalmandi dhaik lain keh woh kehta hai keh
''aorat ko perday ka hukam sirf puranay zamanay kay liyae hee diya gia tha aaj kal kay door main aorat kay liyae perda kerna lazmi nahi hai''.aur ooper say phir kehta hai keh
''music halal hai ''.main aap sab say yeh kehna chahta hon keh woh kameena hamaray ''asool'' per hamla ker chuka hai jis ki tashreeh hamain ''iema_arbah'' nay ker kay dee hai.abhi sirf itna hee kion keh yeh fitna abhi khul raha hai.aur is kay baray main malomat aa rahoio hain.
mager sab say khaternaak baat yeh hai keh hum hee main majod kuch log is ko buhat like kertay hain yani jo log nam nihad roshan khial log hain.kion keh ghaamdi un kay matlab ki baat kerta hai.aorat kay maray is ko buhat like kertay hain kion keh yeh music ko halaal kehta hai aur isi terhaan woh aortain jo perday ko ''inteha pasandi'' kehti hain woh bhee is ko buhat like kertay hain.mager woh becharay nahi samajhtay.
masla yeh hai keh yeh fitnay yani''ghaamdi aur perwaizi''
''deen islam ko apni aqal say chalana chahtay hain'' jo keh sahi nahi hai.
allah hum sab ko in say bachnay ki taofeeq ata fermay. (ameen)
khalil sahib uthain buhat soo liya ab too jaag jain dushman hamaray gher kay ander tak aa chuka hai.

[sarfraz_qamar]

Re: MUBAHISA: Music?

yahan perr joo llooog music kee mukhalfat main bool rahee hain shayd wahee sabb see ziadaa music suntay hoo gee
music sunnann qatatnn islam main haram haii aorr yehh kisee soorat main bhee jayzz nahee hoo saktee haii

[abdulwahab]

Re: MUBAHISA: Music?

yahan perr joo llooog music kee mukhalfat main bool rahee hain shayd wahee sabb see ziadaa music suntay hoo gee

aap kisi kay baray main kuch nahi jantay.:jazak:

[tauruskhan]

Re: Music?

prove with proof........................about ghamdi

have you ever read his books like fanoon etc
bataoon ka mahir hay wo , i agree
but app kisi bi baat ko check kerna ho to us key liya Quran o Hadees sey reference lena perta hay
but he rejects Quran and hadees
only what he likes make it halal and what he don't like make it haram
and sedi baat ko itnay chakar deta hay key app ghomtay he reh jatey haan and at end without any proof apni baat ker jata hay

pehlay main bi us ko accha samjnay laga tha , but when i study him , i found him very very wrong

i would suggest you key ja ker app us ki books perhain

[Shaim]

Re: Music?

have you ever read his books like fanoon etc
bataoon ka mahir hay wo , i agree
but app kisi bi baat ko check kerna ho to us key liya Quran o Hadees sey reference lena perta hay
but he rejects Quran and hadees
only what he likes make it halal and what he don't like make it haram
and sedi baat ko itnay chakar deta hay key app ghomtay he reh jatey haan and at end without any proof apni baat ker jata hay

pehlay main bi us ko accha samjnay laga tha , but when i study him , i found him very very wrong

i would suggest you key ja ker app us ki books perhain

shuker hai u thiik ho gae:tauba
n weldone 4 ur research!:thmbup: