MUBAHISA: Music?

[abdulwahab]

Kia Music Per Ijtehaad Hona Chahiyae?
Yeh ''ghamdi Fitna'' Kehta Hai KEH IJTEHAAD HONA CHAHIYAE YANI MUSIC HONA CHAHIYAE.,aap Kia Kehtay Hai?
Kia Aap Music Suntay Hain??:mm:

[suffard]

Re: Music?

miyaan hosh kay nakhun lo music per ijhtehaad nahi ho sacta yeh haraam hai haraam hai haraam hai.
ghaamdi per lanat
main music nahi sunta.:salam:

[Muhammad Khalil]

Re: Music?

Asal burai hay La elmi hay........

dostoo aap ghamdi sahib ko lahnat ker rahy hu....i m sory to say kia aap ko Ejtihad ka pata hay?

[shaani khalid]

Re: Music?

:mm:

[suffard]

Re: Music?

shyd aap ko bhee maloom ho keh hazoor muhammad (pbuh) ki ihadees bhe hain is kay baray main.

[abdulwahab]

Re: Music?

mr suffard jis nay allah aur us kay rasool(pbuh) kay hukam kay khilaaf koi hukam diya wohi hamara dushman hai.

[*Roomi*]

Re: Music?

Ghamdi = Rejected Man Qool-o-Fail May Tazad Hai us kay

Music Haraam Hai 100%

[sccorpion81]

Re: Music?

agar music haram hai jis say main bhi itifaq kerta hoon tu sawal yeh hai k ham is ko suntay kiun hain???/

[Muhammad Khalil]

Re: Music?

Ghamdi = Rejected Man Qool-o-Fail May Tazad Hai us kay

Music Haraam Hai 100%

prove with proof........................about ghamdi

[abdulwahab]

Re: Music?

prove with proof........................about ghamdi

khalil sahib hum kehtay hainn keh ''ghaamdi'' aik buhat bara fitna hai hamaray liyae yani ummat_e_musalma kay liyae lakin aap us ka saath day rahay hain.
chalain aap mujhay batain keh woh islamic principles kay baray main kehta kia hai????/ zara hum bhee too sunain keh kia hum too kahin galat nahi hain?//
waisay aap ki sahulat kay liyae yeh bata daita hon keh
''ghaamdi ka pura nam hai javaid ahmed ghamdi aur yeh fitna ''idarah_almoorad'' ka serbarah hai.filhaal aap ko itna bata don keh yeh islam kay asool per hamla ker chuka hai.
sab say pehlay aap mujhay batain keh woh kehta kia hai??
phir inshaallah main bhee aap ko bata don ga keh woh kehta kia hai.
waisay aap nay pehlay kaha tha keh
''aap us ki tashreeh karain gay lakin abhi aye nahi hai''

[abdulwahab]

Re: Music?

agar music haram hai jis say main bhi itifaq kerta hoon tu sawal yeh hai k ham is ko suntay kiun hain???/

her koi music nahi sunta.

[Mr. Sialkoty]

Re: Music?

Music mein one sided drum (duff) jaiz he...aur Double sided drum (dhool) wo bhi manadi (ailaan) karanay ke liye.is ke ilawa instruments bajana aur sunana jaiz nahi

[Muhammad Khalil]

Re: Music?

khalil sahib hum kehtay hainn keh ''ghaamdi'' aik buhat bara fitna hai hamaray liyae yani ummat_e_musalma kay liyae lakin aap us ka saath day rahay hain.
chalain aap mujhay batain keh woh islamic principles kay baray main kehta kia hai????/ zara hum bhee too sunain keh kia hum too kahin galat nahi hain?//
waisay aap ki sahulat kay liyae yeh bata daita hon keh
''ghaamdi ka pura nam hai javaid ahmed ghamdi aur yeh fitna ''idarah_almoorad'' ka serbarah hai.filhaal aap ko itna bata don keh yeh islam kay asool per hamla ker chuka hai.
sab say pehlay aap mujhay batain keh woh kehta kia hai??
phir inshaallah main bhee aap ko bata don ga keh woh kehta kia hai.
waisay aap nay pehlay kaha tha keh
''aap us ki tashreeh karain gay lakin abhi aye nahi hai''

yeh to koi baat na hui mera swal hee muj per

[abdulwahab]

Re: Music?

yeh to koi baat na hui mera swal hee muj per

janab aap ko yaad ho ga keh aap nay is thred main start main mujh say kaha tha keh ''main ghaamdi kay baray main jald hee likhon ga''
yeh alag baat hai keh ab aap apni jaan churwa rahay hain.

[abdulwahab]

Re: Music?

yeh alag baat hgai keh aap nay woh baat remove ker di hai yahan say