sufi isam is islamic or not

[tauruskhan]

Asalam-0-Alikum
mera aj app logon sey swal hay key

kia sufi isam is islamic ya naeen
if yes to pir app ko koi Quranic ayat ya hadees reference key liya pesh kerni ho gi
keon key is per tumam ulma karam ka ijtama hay key hmm kisi bi ibadat ya nazriay etc ko islamic us wakat tak naeen keh saktey jab tak key us ka reference hmm ko Quran o Hadees say na mil jaey


sukria

---------------------------------
yahan sufi isam sey meri murad tasufuf key falsafay sey haay
na key sirf Quran o Hadees key alim and neek bandon sey
ok
i hope you got my point

[Muhammad Khalil]

Re: sufi isam is islamic or not

yes vote........

[Baad-e-Saba]

Re: sufi isam is islamic or not

no

voted

[tauruskhan]

Re: sufi isam is islamic or not

yes vote........

thread ka maqsad sirf vouting naeen tha

baat yeh hay key main jab bi kisi esay shaks key pass jata hoon jo key sufi isam per yakeen rakta hay , us sey pochta hoon key
sufi isam ki support main koi Ayat ya hadees to ho gi
to sirf jowab milta hay key " Bhai app naeen jantay , yeh bohat upper ki baat hay "

isi oper ki baat ko talash kerna hay

app ney vote dia key yes
lakin sabit naeen kia keeon

intazar rahey ga app ki post ka

[tauruskhan]

Re: sufi isam is islamic or not

no

voted

thanx for the reply

[ummid]

Re: sufi isam is islamic or not

nice topic.hum apne views kuch dinu baad deinge......us se paihle plzz concluson mat nikal lijye ga.......zyadah se zyadah do ya teen din..hum apne points ke saath aap ko zaror join kareinge....Allah Hafiz..:lpop:

[Muhammad Khalil]

Re: sufi isam is islamic or not

thread ka maqsad sirf vouting naeen tha

baat yeh hay key main jab bi kisi esay shaks key pass jata hoon jo key sufi isam per yakeen rakta hay , us sey pochta hoon key
sufi isam ki support main koi Ayat ya hadees to ho gi
to sirf jowab milta hay key " Bhai app naeen jantay , yeh bohat upper ki baat hay "

isi oper ki baat ko talash kerna hay

app ney vote dia key yes
lakin sabit naeen kia keeon

intazar rahey ga app ki post ka

ager aap os k Qail nahi hain to aap per yeh zuma dari hay k os k Na Jaiz huny kee koi dalil dain....Quran and Hadis sy...

[tauruskhan]

Re: sufi isam is islamic or not

ager aap os k Qail nahi hain to aap per yeh zuma dari hay k os k Na Jaiz huny kee koi dalil dain....Quran and Hadis sy...

kisi cheeze key islami ya ghair islami honey ko is tarah check kia ja sakta hay
key ager us ka reference Quran o Hadees main mil jaey to wo islamic werna non islamic

main ney is per kafi research ki hay , lakin mujeh aik bi ayat ya hadees naeen mili, jis ki waja sey mujeh laga key yeh non islamic hay

lakin pir bi if you know any Quranic ayat ya hadees jis per sey meri nazar na guzri ho , kindly share ker dain

ager aik bi mil gai , to main bi yakeen lay aoon ga

----------------------------

[Shaim]

Re: sufi isam is islamic or not

Nice thread filba bhai!:salam:
i ll join all of u soon:insha:

[tauruskhan]

Re: sufi isam is islamic or not

Sufi'ism

i am sorry to say
app ney ilfaz to bohat acchay istamal key
but
islam sirf Quran o Hadees per mushtamil hay
and islam ki takmeel us ayat key sath complete ho gai thee
key aj hmm ney tum per apna deen mukamal ker dia

ager app key khial main islam complete us wakat naeen hoa tha

to main app ki baat per ghor ker sakta hon

and kindly apni ini batoon ka jowab ager app Quran o Hadees sey dey detay to khosi hoti

kia islamic bateen Quran o Hadees sey hat ker bi ho sakti haan
keeon key app ki batoon sey yahi lag raha hay

[tauruskhan]

Re: sufi isam is islamic or not

aik to app ney apney post ko zabardasti end per jor dia hay

second kisi bi baat ko Quran o Hadees sey sabit naeen ker sakey

[tauruskhan]

sufi isam key gumhra kun akeday per aik nazar

chaleen dosto , masood bahi to
Quran o hadees key alimon ko sufi kehna shorow ho gay haan
to main kuch akaid sufion key share keeon na kar doon

chalen start main aik namoona hi sahi

sofiaon key motabik

Insan khud khuda hay

[tauruskhan]

Re: sufi isam is islamic or not

hmm aik aur wakia bi

[tauruskhan]

Re: sufi isam is islamic or not

lain jee aik aur wakia bi pertay haan
key Khana kaba khud sufia ki kadam bosi key liya jata hay

is this islamic ?

[tauruskhan]

Re: sufi isam is islamic or not

sufia ka dawa hay key wo ilm direct Allah sey hasil kertay haan
kia koi is daway key saboot key liya koi Quranic ayat ya hadees dikha sakta hay